Forum Topics

Was That Wise Hilary?

I've just been looking at some coverage of today's Labour party conference and a bit of a stir has been caused by a delegate from the Ealing Central and Acton constituency Hilary Wise. She made a speech to congress in which she said that the accusations of anti-semitism in the Labour party were overblown and the number of actual instances were miniscule. She blamed the growing the perception that Labour was anti-semitic on neo-Liberals withing the party and the mainstream media. She got a very positive reception from the hall although the chair apparently warned her for some of the language she used. I do wonder if Jeremy Corbyn was in the hall if his heart sank when she got up to speak. He has been spending the last few weeks trying to put this issue to bed and was presumably hoping that the conference would talk about things like renationalisation and higher taxes for the rich. Anything but Jews or Brexit basically. The other thing that really should have given Hilary pause for thought is that people are going to wonder about the motivations of anyone who solely focuses on the activities of Israel. By the standards of the middle east it has killed relatively few of its minorities.  While it is certainly true the Israelis tend to overreact to provocation, provoked they certainly are. The rights that a Palestinian has in Israel are significantly more extensive than they would have in Lebanon. This is an area of the world where there are a lot of bad actors and a lot of governments who don't behave the way they should including Israel. The question really is why do so many people in the Labour party think that it is exclusively the one run by Jews that is a problem?

Dennis O'Shea ● 2913d14 Comments ● 2901d