Forum Topic

George,What's been happening in Southall is simple.Ealing Southall Constituency Labour Party refused to select Cllr Gurcharan Singh as its candidate - for the simple reason that he was not good enough.As a result, Cllr Singh and four of his cronies - all elected under the Labour banner - defected to the Tories.The people of Southall didn't take any notice because they went on to elect a good, principled Labour MP with a thumping majority.Embittered, all that Cllr Singh can now do is go around putting up giant posters of himself and trying to entice every "has been" to defect to the Tories.On May 6, the Southall wards will return an all-Labour slate of councillors and will re-elect the Labour MP. Cllr Singh (now the Tory Parliamentary candidate) will come 3rd behind the Lib Dems.And that will be the end of this silly chapter of Southall's political history.Don't get me wrong, George, I have nothing against people who defect between parties as long as they do so on a point of principle. A case in point is Dick Taverne, who I greatly admire and who in 1973 resigned his Labour seat and fought a by-election on the issue of the Common Market. He won - and was re-elected in the following February's general election - but sadly lost narrowly in October '74. But the thing is, his ideology prevailed (for we are now still in Europe).But I have no admiration at all for Cllr Singh. I cannot see what policy issue made him resign inbetween seeking the Labour nomination at the by-election selection hustings of Thursday 05/07/07 and appearing on Channel Four News as a fully paid-up member of the Conservative Party on Monday 09/07/07.Perhaps someone could explain what his "point of principle" was.

Robin Taylor ● 6158d

Sikhs are the dominant population in Southall. The Sikh Federation wants to see a Sikh in Parliament – come what may.It  was the local Tory Council which did not in the opinion of Southall residents do enough to stop the 1979 riots and the meeting at Southall Town Hall.  The parties of the Right, some led by old Etonii, generally do not so far have a very good record of gaining the confidence of ethnic groups. For instance even now the Tory policy line on immigration comes across as more harsh than the Labour line. Tory Ealing Council has not introduced many far reaching vote forming enticements into Southall. Some in Southall may think that is due to the self interested composition in Cabinet to which Hitesh Tailor alludes.So the numerous defectors must probably find it very hard to gain a huge amount of support. However Mr Sharma represents the Labour Partys’ ills and to some extent his party in Southall will be punished in the next General election. The only constant is the Liberal Mr  Bakhai. He has stood more than once before and increased his position to number two. The Liberal Party can sometimes get the message across that they stand for social justice. History is too old for the Liberals to be associated with the hated white ruling class. At the last bye election the Labour and Tory parties were in disarray. How that must have confused the voters. I suspect they are still confused. So to what extent will the Hindus still support Mr Sharma and also try to keep the Sikhs out; are the Muslims going to vote for the Tories (I would be surprised); will the Sikhs vote Tory simply because with defections and the general mood of the country, they can see the possibility of a turbaned Sikh in Parliament;  and what will the whiter ethnic  wards in the rest of the constituency be doing because none of the candidates national or local seem to manage to get across that they have been working actively for those communities as well? In whom can the voters place trust?With such a mix of issues plus the many which I am sure are there but which I do not know about, it will be an up and a downer election to watch. It is a shame that both Graham and Robin refuse to give us further insights, despite their experience of local politics. Pussyfooting and the suspension of thought just will not wash. With such a tangle of submarine interests in Southall I do not see how you can realistically assess the merit of the candidates in advance - from a national politics point of view. The election will be a local bun fight driven by an agenda only part of which will be visible. If Labour skimps home with a much lower majority, then expect more local shenanigans. Hitesh might be fairly certain that the Cabinet will not want further complications, when the subsequent election they will be looking at will be a judgement on the rule of Cameroons.Perhaps I should register a protest by voting Green.

George Knox ● 6152d

The vote WILL go against the Southall Tories next year, and if they've got any sense they will then allow themselves to sink into obscurity.No one has yet mentioned on this thread that the newly re-drawn Ealing Southall constituency is much LESS white (it loses two - or is it three - mainly white wards in the Ealing area) and much MORE Asian (being, as a consequence, more dominated by the five Southall wards).That simple fact alone makes it more hopeless for the Tories at the parliamentary level.The only chance the Tories have got - and it is an outside chance - is that they may attempt to use the religious card to try and hold their defectors' seats in Southall Broadway Ward.The crucial thing here is that the three Tory candidates comprise two Sikhs and one Hindu; whereas the three Labour candidates comprise two Muslims and one Hindu.About a half of the population of the ward is Sikh, and only one quarter Muslim. The important thing to bear in mind (if you're English) is that Asian people can tell the difference between a Sikh, Hindu and Muslim name: they're all very distinctive. The Tories will try to make play of this (I know, because when the defectors were in the Labour Party, I campaigned alongside them and observed their tactics).They will hope that this factor - combined with a sizeable Tory lead in the nationwide polls - will enable them to squeeze out a victory. Certainly, some elderly traditional Sikhs - who would normally vote Labour - might find their loyalty tested when confronted with a ballot sheet that has Muslim Labour candidates and Sikh Tory candidates.The other defectors' ward - Lady Margaret - is one where the Tories have very little chance because although it is the ward that Gurcharan Singh is defending, as far as I know Labour may have selected a Sikh/Hindu ticket to stand against him. (I'm not 100% sure about this but I do know that at least one of Labour's candidates there is a Hindu woman, and Sikhs really tend not to discriminate against Hindu candidates). Personally, I still think Labour will make a clean sweep of all the Southall wards, because too many in the younger Asian generation have a secular outlook (and also because some residents think that Gurcharan Singh and his colleagues have made themselves look like fools).Whatever happens though, expect a massive turnout - especially in Southall Broadway Ward - where the likelihood of the Tories playing the religious card is sure to result in the Mosques and Gurdwaras mobilising their efforts behind their respective candidates.

Robin Taylor ● 6151d