Forum Topics

Possible changes to the British electoral system.

With the latest general election decided it would appear that the first-past-the-post (FPP) system may possibly be on its way out.With the coalition between the Lib. Dems. and Conservative parties it would seem inevitable that some form of proportional representation will eventually be adopted. Now is the time to give serious thought as to which form of PR will best suit Britain.Having been born in London and raised in Hanwell I now reside in New Zealand and have experienced both election systems. Most will know that some years ago New Zealand opted to go the PR route having abandoned FPP.We were offered a system called Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) which was adopted by referendum. MMP is by no means ideal as it led to anomalies which are undesirable in a democratic country. I hope we will change this at some point in the future.MMP inevitably meant that some members were returned at the whim of their parties as they are on the unelected "list" and do not represent constituencies. A fairer system in my opinion is the Single Transferable Vote (STV) system in which the "list" members are voted in by the people and are not just "vote fodder" at the convenience of the parties. I believe a similar system is used by some EU countries.The other main fault, as you will shortly discover, is that coalitions invariably lead to compromise. On some issues the minority tail will frequently wag the majority dog. Such decisions are usually anathema to the majority of voters. This is happening in New Zealand today mainly with respect to Maori issues where we appear to be happy to give away the family silver.After the "Dave and Nick Show" honeymoon period ends the sparks will surely fly.Good luck for the future.

John Chant ● 5973d1 Comments ● 5973d